A local historic preservation committee approved a series of restoration and improvement projects Tuesday to safeguard St. Thomas’s architectural heritage while addressing accessibility, safety, and community needs.
Commissioners first approved a plan to restore the front plaza of Dronningens Gade 35, known as the Hibiscus Alley building, using salvaged historic Chicago bricks. The project will remove tripping hazards while preserving the area’s historic character, with staff and board members agreeing that the proposed brick pattern reflects the district’s traditional aesthetic.
A more complex discussion surrounded Villa Britannia, where owner Steve Stigler sought approval for a second-story addition, a new swimming pool, and the creation of off-street parking. While the board approved the building extension and pool, concerns about the parking plan’s impact on the historic streetscape and compliance with zoning requirements led to a continuance. Commissioners emphasized the need for further development of the parking proposal, citing both practical and preservation concerns.
The board also gave the green light to Buoyant Living Wellness Studios for the installation of a four-square-foot hanging sign at Dronningens Gade 32. “The sign will feature a round logo with white script lettering designed to be simple, tasteful and historically compatible with the district. It will be mounted on a rock iron bracket, similar in style to those already present in the area,” said Nisha Charles, representing Buoyant Living Wellness Studios.
Representatives from Sts. Peter and Paul Catholic Church presented plans to expand the perimeter wall and add fencing around the school’s sports court. The proposal, intended to enhance student safety and privacy, drew suggestions from staff and commissioners to maintain architectural consistency with existing wall motifs and materials. The board recommended continuing the current wall height and design for a cohesive appearance.
The Queen Louise Boys and Girls Club building will undergo a comprehensive restoration to repair hurricane damage, strengthen structural elements, and improve ADA accessibility. The project, presented by Habiba Bell of Harnell Engineering and Construction, includes exterior repairs, new ramps, and interior upgrades to support after-school programs for local youth. The committee also encouraged the installation of a historic plaque to honor the building’s legacy.
In the Kongens Quarter, the committee approved the partial demolition of non-historic, structurally unsound additions to a family property with deep local roots. The plan will remove hazardous concrete elements to protect the recently restored historic structure and create off-street parking, with future restoration of a historic kitchen also under consideration.
At Norre Gade 4B, the committee reviewed and approved modifications to window and shutter designs for a recently constructed building. The changes, prompted by noncompliance with previous approvals, will bring the building in line with district aesthetics and include the addition of traditional mullions to windows, enhancing the site’s historic character.
Finally, the Moravian Church at Estate Nisky received approval to remove a large, termite-infested tree posing a safety hazard. “The tree has been through many weather conditions over the years, and with time, has begun to deteriorate. At this point, we have to look at our options and are asking for guidance and direction, as far as trimming or totally removing the tree, as it has become a hazard,” said Gail Chinnery, representing the Moravian Church Virgin Islands Conference. The committee stipulated that the beehive within the tree be safely relocated, that a new tree be planted, and that usable wood be repurposed.
